Late Whistle

Call types

What goes uncalled, and what gets called wrong

Two separate rates for each call type. Missed calls: plays the league says should have been whistled, out of all graded non-calls. Incorrect calls: whistles the league says were wrong, out of all graded whistles.

Missed-call rate

Share of graded non-calls that were missed, all seasons, 95% intervals. Types with 30+ graded non-calls.
Foul: Defense 3 Second
41.7%
Turnover: Traveling
40.6%
Turnover: 24 Second Violation
38.2%
Turnover: 3 Second Violation
36.0%
Turnover: Stepped out of Bounds
20.1%
Turnover: 5 Second Violation
19.6%
Violation: Kicked Ball
15.0%
Turnover: Lost Ball Out of Bounds
11.8%
Foul: Away from Play
10.4%
Foul: Loose Ball
8.3%
Violation: Defensive Goaltending
7.9%
Stoppage: Out-of-Bounds
7.5%
Foul: Shooting
6.0%
Foul: Personal
5.3%
Foul: Offensive
4.5%

Incorrect-call rate

Share of graded whistles that were wrong, all seasons, 95% intervals. Types with 30+ graded whistles.
Turnover: Traveling
13.4%
Foul: Away from Play
7.9%
Stoppage: Out-of-Bounds
7.1%
Violation: Kicked Ball
6.7%
Foul: Offensive
6.4%
Foul: Shooting
5.9%
Turnover: Stepped out of Bounds
4.0%
Foul: Loose Ball
3.8%
Turnover: Lost Ball Out of Bounds
3.7%
Foul: Personal
2.3%
Turnover: 5 Second Violation
1.7%
Turnover: Out of Bounds - Bad Pass Turn
0.9%
Instant Replay: Overturn Ruling
0.7%
Turnover: 24 Second Violation
0.6%
Foul: Personal Take
0.2%
Instant Replay: Support Ruling
0.2%
Violation: Defensive Goaltending
0.0%

The numbers

Call typeGradedWhistlesIncorrectRateNon-callsMissedRate
Foul: Defense 3 Second1,16360–1,15748241.7%
Turnover: Traveling2,0652773713.4%1,78872640.6%
Turnover: 24 Second Violation55952530.6%341338.2%
Turnover: 3 Second Violation558112–54719736.0%
Foul: Personal Take81680920.2%72–
Turnover: Stepped out of Bounds50820084.0%3086220.1%
Turnover: 5 Second Violation3356011.7%2755419.6%
Violation: Kicked Ball332179126.7%1532315.0%
Turnover: Lost Ball Out of Bounds471437163.7%34411.8%
Foul: Away from Play7118977.9%6226510.4%
Foul: Loose Ball9,0961,017393.8%8,0796678.3%
Violation: Defensive Goaltending41313600.0%277227.9%
Stoppage: Out-of-Bounds1,3831,237887.1%146117.5%
Foul: Shooting26,3705,6003335.9%20,7701,2476.0%
Foul: Personal29,91010,4522372.3%19,4581,0275.3%
Foul: Offensive18,722715466.4%18,0078064.5%
Instant Replay: Support Ruling89987020.2%290–
Instant Replay: Overturn Ruling31029820.7%120–
Turnover: Out of Bounds - Bad Pass Turn43743740.9%00–

All seasons since 2015, call types with at least 300 graded plays. Rates on fewer than 30 plays are not shown. Missed-call rates depend on what the league chose to grade, which changed over time; see Methods.